An investigation by the BBC’s Global Disinformation Unit has revealed that Steven Bartlett, host of the Diary of a CEO podcast, has been promoting harmful health misinformation through his platform. The podcast, which has gained immense popularity for its in-depth interviews, has recently come under scrutiny for failing to challenge unfounded health claims made by guests, including statements about cancer treatments and vaccines.
Unfounded Claims and Limited Oversight
Recent episodes have featured guests promoting controversial and disproven ideas such as treating cancer with a ketogenic diet instead of conventional methods and dismissing the efficacy of evidence-based treatments like chemotherapy. Experts warn that such unchallenged claims can foster distrust in medical science and potentially lead to dangerous health decisions.
In an analysis of 15 health-focused episodes, experts found an average of 14 misleading or harmful claims per episode. Dr. David Grimes, a cancer researcher, emphasized the risks:
“Promoting unproven treatments can lead patients away from evidence-based care, resulting in worse health outcomes.”
Shift in Content and Growing Controversy
Initially focused on business and entrepreneurship, The Diary of a CEO has shifted toward health-related topics over the past 18 months. The change coincided with a rise in viewership on Bartlett’s YouTube channel, which grew from 9 million to 15 million monthly views.
While Bartlett has defended his podcast as a platform for open dialogue, critics argue that hosting discredited voices, such as Dr. Aseem Malhotra, who falsely claimed COVID-19 vaccines were a “net negative for society,” amplifies harmful misinformation. The World Health Organization has consistently credited vaccines with saving millions of lives.
The Role of Financial Interests
Bartlett’s investments in health and wellness companies, such as meal replacement brand Huel and personalized nutrition platform Zoe, have raised questions about potential conflicts of interest. Critics, including Cécile Simmons of the Institute for Strategic Dialogue, point out that financial stakes may influence the podcast’s focus and guest selection.
Two ads featuring Bartlett promoting Huel and Zoe were recently banned by the UK’s Advertising Standards Authority for failing to disclose his financial ties.
Unregulated Content and the Risks
Podcasts in the UK are not regulated by Ofcom, leaving platforms like The Diary of a CEO free from strict accuracy and impartiality standards. Bartlett has defended airing controversial views, stating that “the truth is usually somewhere in the middle.”
However, experts argue that presenting unproven health claims alongside evidence-based science creates confusion and undermines public trust in medical institutions. Dr. Liz O’Riordan, a cancer surgeon, warned:
“Simplistic solutions to complex health problems can divert people from life-saving treatments.”
Moving Forward
As the podcast continues to grow in popularity, public health advocates call for greater accountability and fact-checking to prevent the spread of misinformation. While Bartlett’s production company, Flight Studio, emphasizes a commitment to diverse perspectives, experts stress the importance of ensuring discussions are grounded in scientific evidence.
For listeners seeking accurate health information, experts recommend consulting reputable sources and medical professionals rather than relying on unverified claims in entertainment media.
Source: BBC
Leave a comment